Oral History Interview with
Robert G. Nixon
News correspondent with the International News Service,
1930-58; served as editor of the service for a time. He first came to
Washington, D.C., in 1938 where he served as their State Department and
foreign relations correspondent. He was a war correspondent, attached
to the British army in France and Belgium, 1940, during invasion of the
low countries; evacuated from Dunkirk but later returned to France; evacuated
with remnants of the British army from Brest, June 20, 1940; covered London
Blitz, 1940-41; war correspondent, attached to United States forces in
European theater of operations, 1942-1943; correspondent in Northern Ireland,
United Kingdom, and Mediterranean theater, participating in North African
invasion and campaign. Covered Casablanca conference, 1943; Quebec conference,
1944; and Potsdam, 1945. Washington correspondent covering the White House
beginning in 1944.
Bethesda, Maryland
October 21, 1970
by Jerry N. Hess
[Notices and Restrictions | Interview
Transcript | Additional Nixon Oral History Transcripts]
NOTICE
This is a transcript of a tape-recorded interview conducted for the Harry
S. Truman Library. A draft of this transcript was edited by the interviewee
but only minor emendations were made; therefore, the reader should remember
that this is essentially a transcript of the spoken, rather than the written
word.
Numbers appearing in square brackets (ex. [45]) within the transcript indicate the pagination in the original, hardcopy version of the oral history interview.
RESTRICTIONS
This oral history transcript may be read, quoted from, cited, and reproduced
for purposes of research. It may not be published in full except by permission
of the Harry S. Truman Library.
Opened December, 1978
Harry S. Truman Library
Independence, Missouri
[Top of the Page | Notices
and Restrictions | Interview Transcript
| Additional Nixon Oral History Transcripts]
Oral History Interview with Robert G. Nixon
Bethesda, Maryland
October 21, 1970
by Jerry N. Hess
[283]
HESS: Mr. Nixon, let's continue on with the Potsdam Conference.
NIXON: I think I had mentioned what a pleasant voyage this turned out
to be.
HESS: There is one point. We have [William M.] Rigdon's log, and we have
a list of the President's party. Should we mention some of the men who
were on the trip?
NIXON: Well, perhaps briefly.
We've covered Jimmy Byrnes. Fleet Admiral William D. Leahy was along.
He had been Roosevelt's Chief of Staff. A remarkable and very able man.
During the war, he perhaps was Roosevelt's closest adviser. He then became
Chief of Staff to Truman, and continued in that role for a number of years.
I had occasion to phone him one day after
[284] he retired. It turned out to
be very sad. I don't recall why I needed to talk with him, but his aide
answered the phone. He said that Leahy was ailing, but Leahy picked up
the phone, and we talked a little. I remember that it was a very sad occasion,
because Leahy said, "Bob, I'd love to see you, but I can't. I'm very ill
and I'm dying." He died shortly afterwards.
Well, he was along, and he was the President's chief adviser on military
matters.
Rosenman, Special Assistant to the President, was with us. What part
he took in the Conference, if any, I frankly don't know. The reason for
him being along was to write a speech for the President, which he undertook
on our return trip aboard the Augusta. This was a report to the
Congress and the American people on the Potsdam Conference. I'm not sure,
but I know that was his obvious reason for going along. Others such as
Harry Vaughan and Dick Vardaman, the
[285] Military and Naval Aides at the time,
were along just because they were part of the President's staff. They
were just fulfilling the normal role of the Military and Naval Aides.
They really were along just for show.
Freeman Matthews, Chip Bohlen, and Benjamin Cohen were all from the State
Department. Their role was as advisers to the President. Chip Bohlen's
role was a double one. In addition to being the top Russian expert in
the State Department, he was also fluent in the Russian language, and
he was the President's interpreter at these sessions.
Stalin, of course, conducted everything in the Russian language. They
didn't go back to the Congress of Vienna, or earlier international conferences,
where the French language was the language of diplomacy. They used their
own languages.
Bohlen was a very valuable man. Afterwards
[286] he was made Ambassador to
Russia, which was a continuation of a longtime assignment to Moscow.
Walter Brown was Jimmy Byrnes' errand boy, or aide if you want to call
him that. Brown was from Byrnes' home state. Earlier he had been a newspaperman.
When Byrnes was made Secretary of State, he hired Brown and put him in
the State Department as his assistant. That was his capacity in going
to the Potsdam Conference. Also Jimmy Byrnes was going to write a book
later, and Brown was along to corral all of the information he possibly
could in behalf of Byrnes to be put into this book, which I'm sure Brown
had a great deal to do with writing.
The rest of them were just the people you would expect to be along.
For instance, Captain Frank Graham was in the Map Room at the White House
from the U.S. Army. He was a Map Room watch officer. He was along in this
capacity, but he also worked with
[287] White House communications.
Lt. William "Bill" Rigdon was along in the capacity of a stenographer.
I notice on this list that he's down as personal secretary to the President,
which is fair enough, but his function was to take down in shorthand the
minutes of meetings. That's the function that he had at the White House
and also on any and all of these trips that the President took.
Captain Alphonse McMahon, Medical Corps, U.S. Navy, was personal physician
to the President at that time. He very shortly afterwards was succeeded
by Wally Graham, who then was a colonel and rapidly became a brigadier
general because Truman promoted him. Wally then remained the President's
personal physician throughout the rest of the time in the White House.
He was from Kansas City, and his father had earlier been physician to
Truman. There was a very close attachment there. That is really why the
President
[288] made him his personal physician.
Charlie Ross was Press Secretary to the President. His role was obvious.
Then there are these others, members of the Secret Service. Leahy's aide,
Julius Edelstein, who was a lieutenanant in the Naval Reserve; George
Elsey, who was then a lieutenant in the Navy and also a White House Map
Room watch officer. He later became more and more important around the
White House. He had a role similar to Clark Clifford and Charlie Murphy.
He is now head of the American Red Cross.
Well, that about covers it.
HESS: I noticed that there were very few newsmen who went along on this
particular trip.
NIXON: Oh, that's right.
HESS: Why was it decided to hold down the number of newsmen who went?
How was it decided who would go? How are those decisions made?
[289]
NIXON: Well, there are four names here, my own, Merriman Smith of the
UP, Anthony Vaccaro of the AP, and Morgan Beatty, the radio announcer
with NBC. He was taken along to cover for all the radio networks.
HESS: As a pool man.
NIXON: He was a pool man. This was before the television era came in.
I notice also that Jack Romagna's name is down here as secretary to Mr.
Ross. I also see that he remained in England for a visit. That is why
Rigdon became the President's stenographer because ordinarily Romagna
was the White House stenographer and took all the private minutes of meetings
and all the President's top secret papers and dictation and that sort
of thing.
The reason that there were only four newsmen aboard was that this was
the ordinary order of things. On all the wartime trips that Roosevelt
[290]
made, there were only three newspaper correspondents permitted to go along.
They were the representatives of the three news services. I was the representative
of International News Service, and then there was the UP and AP. We traveled
with the President. That was our role to be with him all the time, wherever
he went, and on this occasion, the radio networks were permitted to have
a man along.
HESS: Before we move on may I ask you just a general question about your
relationship with your principal competitors--the reporters from the other
news agencies. Just what was your relationships with those gentlemen?
NIXON: We got along. It was a marriage of convenience. It must be remembered
that perhaps there is no more highly competitive business in the world
than the newspaper business. The three news services were intensely competitive.
Each tried to beat the other, twenty-four hours a
[291] day. Each worked completely
independently. The relationships, under these circumstances, depended
upon the individuals. Despite the competitive atmosphere, some were pretty
nice guys. Some could be quite the reverse. It was a throat cutting business
most of the time. I don't think it would be right for me to mention any
personalities. If I mention the good guys in the white hats, I'd have
to mention the bad guys in the black hats; so I had better drop it there.
HESS: I think in our chronology of our trip to Potsdam, we are pretty
well to Europe. What do you recall about the events after the ship reached
Europe?
NIXON: As I said yesterday, this was a most unusual route that we followed
across the Atlantic. It was right over the top of the globe, just a straight
line out of Norfolk. It was many, many hundreds of miles away from any
of the shipping lanes.
[292] Incidentally, there would be no German U-boats
there, whatsoever, had any remained. I am sure that is the reason this
route was chosen. You see, the U-boats hovered in the shipping lanes.
Anyway, when we came into the English Channel off the south coast of
England, around Plymouth, it was a beautiful, crystal clear, bracing morning.
We were met there by an escort of destroyers from the English fleet. It
was quite impressive. All of the personnel on the destroyers "lined the
rail" in their Sunday best, shoulder to shoulder in their colorful uniforms,
along the main deck of the destroyers from bow to stern. Salutes were
exchanged. The panoply of vessels from two fleets meeting each other were
gone through.
We went on up through the Straits of Dover past the White Cliffs of Dover.
We went on then into the Scheldt, which is the river approach to Antwerp.
We got to Antwerp, and who was on the
[293] dock but Dwight D. Eisenhower. Standing
there on the dock alone awaiting for the President to arrive. He came
aboard and was greeted by the President, and they went off to the President's
cabin for a chat.
Antwerp had been bombed considerably. But the destruction didn't seem
to be too heavy in the port we saw. In other words, it was still an operational
port and an operational city, though heavily damaged.
We then left by motor car for Brussels. The President traveled in a White
House car with the top down. We were met there (in addition to Eisenhower)
by a man in mourning coat and striped trousers and top hat. He really
looked a little ridiculous. He, of course, was our own Ambassador to Belgium,
Charles Sawyer. Truman later made him Secretary of Commerce. After all
this, he turned on Truman, as so many others did.
From Antwerp to Brussels, was about thirty-five
[294] or forty miles. The entire
route was lined (a few yards apart, on both sides of the road) by American
soldiers standing at attention.
We went immediately from Brussels out to the Army airfield. The President
got in one Air Force plane, and Byrnes got in another one. This was a
separation in case of accident. They took off immediately for Berlin,
landing at the Gatow Airfield, which had been a Luftwaffe airfield adjacent
to Potsdam. We lost them there. The rest of the party had to wait for
a plane to be brought up. There was a lot of air movement, so it took
some time for the airways to be cleared for us to take off.
I remember it was a dreadfully hot day. We were cooped up in a DC-3.
When we finally took off the pilot of the plane, a young Air Force colonel,
invited me to come up and sit in the pilot's cabin with him in the copilot's
seat. With the windows open on both sides, I finally
[295] got some fresh air
and cooled off. I felt sorry for the other men, who couldn't be up there.
We flew in a very short while across Belgium into Germany. I remember
he asked me if I would like to take a little tour. I was not adverse to
it at all. So, he then flew us all over the Ruhr, this great industrial
valley of Western Germany.
This, without a doubt, was the most appalling sight that had ever met
my eyes. Our Flying Fortresses and the British air force Lancasters, had
literally pulverized Western Germany, the industrial part. At Cologne,
the great cathedral was purposefully spared. The freight yards were almost
adjacent to this great and magnificent gothic cathedral and the big station
was there, but everything else was a shamble.
The railroad tracks were a great snarl. It looked like somebody had thrown
great coils of barbed wire around, but they were torn and
[296] twisted and
thrust into the air in great semi-circles of twisted metal two and three
stories high. The entire Ruhr (and this is a vast area), was in the same
condition. Destruction was everywhere.
We flew up the Rhine from Cologne. It was the same thing. The
young pilot was flying at just around a thousand feet, which is almost
on the ground, so we got a very detailed and graphic look at this destruction.
After this trip, which took hours, we headed across Germany for Berlin.
I remember we flew over what had been two cities.
The roofs of the houses and buildings in smaller German towns were tiled.
They were molded tiles very similar to the types of tiles the Spaniards
use on their houses. Some were golden yellow, others were brick red. One
town, had had yellow tile on the roofs and as we flew over there was nothing
left, except in one instance a
[297] great splotch of yellow where the bombs
had pulverized, not only the buildings, but the tiles.
From the air Berlin reminded me of one of those graphic drawings that
illustrates Dante's inferno. Here was one of the largest and oldest cities
in Europe, just an utter shambles. Berlin had had one of the finest subway
systems in Europe. Block after block of the streets that had been over
the subways were just great gorges in the earth between a few standing
walls of the buildings that had been gutted by bomb destruction and fire.
Where the streets had fallen in on top of the subways, from two thousand
feet in the air, you could smell the effluvia of the unburied dead. It
was a ghastly sight. Even though the Germans had been our foe,
it sort of wrenched my heart. They brought it on themselves. They followed
Hitler. It was just too bad, millions dead.
[298]
Again this nice Air Force colonel was having a ball himself. He took
us on quick tours, flying us around over the city to let us see this ghastly
sight. Then we landed at Tempelhof, the principal Berlin airport.
We got in Army jeeps and went out to a suburb near Potsdam where we were
quartered in very fine German homes that had been taken over on a street
called Katerinastrasse. Press headquarters had been set up there by the
Army. We were some distance from the President's villa and Potsdam proper,
but close enough to be readily accessible.
Stalin, as I recall, had not arrived. He was in one of his moods. He
wasn't about to be the first on the scene. These big shots really are
strange.
There's a story told about the head of state who attended the Congress
of Vienna. I believe this was the peace conference held to slice up Europe
after Napoleon was finally defeated at Waterloo.
[299] As the story goes, the
Chiefs of State from five countries met in this place in Vienna. It was
found that there were only four doors going into the room, but there were
five Chiefs of State. So, before the Congress could begin their deliberations,
they had to have a fifth door cut through the wall so that no one would
be in a position of lesser degree than the others. This in a sense was
what was going on there at Berlin.
Stalin decided he was going to be the last one to arrive, which meant
in their strange fashion that he was the real big shot. Truman and Churchill,
with Attlee, had already arrived. It was a couple of days before Stalin
came on the scene. Meanwhile, Truman had a ball, and I'll be glad to tell
you about it.
Truman was a restless man and liked to be on the move. He was full of
beans and energy most of the time. When he learned that Stalin
[300] hadn't
arrived, he took off for a blue plate special tour of ruined Berlin. This
gave us our first level view of the ruins of Berlin.
The Russians had brought in bulldozers and cleared a few streets. Everything
before this had been impassable. The rubble from these destroyed buildings
were two and even three stories high on either side of the streets that
had been cleared. We went all through Berlin, where it was passable. First
we went to what had been Hitler's headquarters, the Reich Chancellory.
This was very close to the Brandenburg Gate.
Truman went into Hitler's headquarters, which was only partially in ruins.
Large areas of some of the floor had collapsed. I remember particularly,
the large inner circular room, just beyond where Hitler's quarters were.
The floor was partially down. He had to walk around a narrow ledge thirty
or forty feet to get beyond it.
[301]
We went out into the yard, I guess you'd call it. This was really a vast
area of central Berlin with gardens, buildings, and palaces. It was a
very elaborate layout. Goering's quarters were in this great area, as
was the SS Secret Police headquarters. In other words, this was the
center of the Hitler regime.
We went out into the side court where you could still see the blackened
spot where Hitler's body had been burned by his aides after he had shot
his mistress and then shot himself. You could also see where Goebbels
poisoned his children and wife and killed himself. This took place in
the immediately adjacent bomb shelter, which went deeply underground.
Truman didn't want to go down in the bomb shelter, and none of us did.
There were Russian guards on duty anyway.
I believe I still have a photograph of Truman and Byrnes in the car with
the top down,
[302] outside of the entrance to the chancellory.
Then we toured other parts of Berlin. The Brandenburg Gate was all scarred
from Russian artillery fire. In the once beautiful park, that lay beyond
the Brandenburg Gate, there wasn't a tree left standing. Weapons were
still lying around.
I remember seeing some of the strange devices that the Russians had.
They were small, steel, treaded, box like contraptions, trailing an electric
cable. These were sent by the Russian troops over the land to where the
Germans were or to where a German tank would be, to blow it up.
HESS: Remote control?
NIXON: Yes.
I climbed the roof of the Reich Chancellory, which was pretty badly damaged,
and this was three or four stories above the street. I went up
[303] to get
a view around. Unexploded Russian rockets were still sticking through
this concrete roof. These little rockets reminded me of the small rockets
we used in our anti-tank rocket launchers, only they were larger and the
Russians called them Katushkas. Katushka being a girl's name.
We saw the ruins of the Reichstag.
Everybody in the party, including Truman was glad to be able to get a
firsthand look at what had happened--Berlin having been taken by the Russians.
HESS: Do you recall any comments that Mr. Truman may have made during
this tour?
NIXON: No, I really don't. Most of the time he and Jimmy Byrnes were
sitting together in the car. When I was able to stand immediately behind
the car, they were just chit-chatting. I may have made a note of this
at the time, but it's too long ago.
[304] Let's see. There was something.
Sitting in the car outside of the entrance to the Reich Chancellory,
Truman said to Byrnes and the others of us around: "The destruction is
really terrible isn't it, but they brought it on themselves." Yes, I do
remember it now.
After this grand tour, the President and Byrnes returned to their villa.
The villa that had been turned over for American use by the Russians at
Potsdam. It seems to me that the following day, there was still no Stalin.
So, this time we took off to review our troops. We had not taken Berlin;
we stopped by agreement on the Elbe.
HESS: What's your opinion of that? Do you think we should have taken
Berlin?
NIXON: Well, that is a great question isn't it? As events transpired,
it would have been better had we taken it. But, I sympathized with the
[305] decision, and I'll tell you why.
This was a military decision and not a political decision. You have to
know the full facts of what was going on. Here were two great powerful
armies approaching each other from opposite fronts with the remains of
the German army caught in between them. We had to prevent an accidental
clash between our own army and our ally's army.
That was the situation, and that is why this decision was made. At Yalta
it had been decided that there would be three occupation zones for the
three armies, plus the French who were given a part of ours.
HESS: We had no ironclad guarantee of access to Berlin.
NIXON: That is where our diplomatic people failed in their responsibility.
HESS: At this time in history, do you recall that
[306] being mentioned?
NIXON: Apparently it never occurred to anybody. Roosevelt felt that this
was tacitly understood. If you (and let's carry it a little further) have
agreed that the American army, the British army, and the Russian army
shall jointly occupy Berlin, then it goes without saying, that under that
agreement, you will have access to Berlin. I am positive that is what
went on in their minds. It never occurred to anyone that we might be shut
off from Berlin. We had the corridor then.
Why did he let the Germans take Berlin? Well, Eisenhower has had his
own latter day explanation. He explained in his book the military reasons
surrounding it. They are easily accessible.
As I was saying, Berlin was to be jointly occupied, but the Russian zone
of occupation was there in the east. Therefore, it was left
[307] to the Russians
to take Berlin. We were to stop on the Elbe, which we did. It's not too
far from Berlin.
As I say, actually three great armies (Eisenhower's, Montgomery's, and
the Russians) coming together with the foe being pressed between them,
and with all the weapons of war being used, how are you going to prevent
a clash of allied armies closing in on the foe. You have to have a stopping
point.
At that time, the Germans weren't fighting us anymore. They were
coming back in droves and surrendering through sheer fright of the Russians.
They feared that they might not be killed, but taken captive by the Russians.
The shooting had really stopped on our part at the Elbe, while the Russians
were crushing the remainder of the German army in Berlin. There, after
that, the shooting stopped. So, there were no untoward incidents as might
otherwise have happened.
[308]
Also, remember that Roosevelt, on his way back from Yalta had pointed
out that the Russians were our allies. And, as he said, "You have to trust
your allies. You have to believe in them. They have to believe in you."
Thus, mistakes are made in history, but hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Especially if you're the opposition political party, having had none of
the responsibility for making these decisions. The people with no responsibility
are the ones who are the greatest critics of those who had to make the
decision.
The Russians had cleaned up the remains of the fighting in Berlin. All
you had to do was look around and see how fierce it was. There was tremendous
destruction.
An armored division of our own was brought in from the Elbe for a review.
This armored division looked good. They were lined up with their new Pershing
tanks and artillery and all
[309] the panoply of an armored division: vehicles,
ammunition carriers, heaven knows what all. They were all lined up along
the Autobahn. You would never have thought that they had been in battle.
Knowing that they were going to be reviewed by the President, all of these
vehicles were just as clean as a pin. They had been completely refurbished.
They had been repainted. They had been sprayed with army green. The yellow
star identified our armor and other vehicles. All of the troops and officers
were in spanking clean new uniforms, even their helmets had been resprayed
with paint. In other words, here was an armored division on parade as
they would have looked at home, without a sign of the grime of battle.
The President, and I guess Byrnes was along with him, in an open car
drove up and down past this armored division that was sprawled out really
for miles along the Autobahn. That was his second day of waiting for Stalin
to arrive.
[310]
When this was over with, back he went to Potsdam to his villa. I went
back to my villa to write my dispatch to be sent back home.
It was the next day that Stalin arrived. The conference began in the
former Crown Prince Wilhelm's villa, Sans Souci. Before the conferences
began, there were protocol visits back and forth: Stalin to Truman, and
Stalin to Churchill, Truman to Stalin, Truman to Churchill. My recollection
is that while they were waiting for Stalin to get off of his pot and get
there for the meeting, that Truman and Churchill had taken advantage of
the delay in Stalin's arrival to get acquainted themselves.
As we know, the relationship between Churchill and Roosevelt was extremely
intimate. They had met repeatedly during the war--with Churchill flying
back and forth in the bombay of a British bomber in what he called his
siren suit. But this was the first direct contact between Truman
[311] and Churchill.
Both were anxious to look the other over and get acquainted. While waiting
for Stalin, they were having luncheons and dinners. Then Stalin arrived
and the conferences started.
Stimson, who was Secretary of War, came over. It was while he was there
that he received a message from Washington, which said: "Baby is born."
Stimson then went to Truman and said, "Mr. President, we have exploded
an atomic bomb successfully at Alamogordo in the New Mexico desert."
This was the realization of the long, more than two billion dollar search,
to bring this incredible explosive into being. After Roosevelt's death
Truman was sworn in, in the Cabinet Room at 7:09 p.m. by the Chief Justice.
Stimson, later in the evening, had come to Truman and related, very briefly,
the facts about the
[312] search to bring this atomic bomb into being.
In his role as head of this war investigating committee, Truman had,
unknowingly, gotten on to this search for the atomic bomb. His investigators
had found out about these enormous expenditures in Washington State and
at Oak Ridge in Tennessee. Nobody knew what was going on. At least, nobody
in Congress knew. This was one of the most carefully kept secrets of the
war. It was kept from everybody but the Russians.
HESS: Had you, as a newsman here in Washington, heard anything about
this?
NIXON: Only in a very indefinable way.
HESS: What had you heard?
NIXON: I knew that something big was going on. It had been suggested
to me in the lobby of the White House one day in a conversation. I can't
remember with whom. It was implied that there
[313] might one day be a new powerful
weapon created by fission--the splitting of the atom.
This, frankly, didn't mean anything to me. I had majored in chemical
engineering at Georgia Tech. I was familiar with the Einstein theory,
upon which the splitting of the atom was founded, which came into being,
I believe, in 1922. Anybody in chemistry or physics knew about the Einstein
theory. Remember it was a theory, not a fact. When I was in England,
early in the war, I had known about the German search to split the atom
with heavy water, and what was going on in Norway where there were sources
of tremendous hydroelectric power which was needed for that type of thing.
I knew why the British had carried off all of those hit and run raids
into Norway. They raided Narvik and Tromso and heaven only knows what
other cities. I knew about the bombing that was going on in Norway, and
I knew they were after the heavy water
[314] plants. In theory none of this
was new to me at all.
So, my reaction to this little discussion was, well here's more theory.
I didn't have any information that we were about to get it. It was a carefully
kept secret. When these rumors got to Truman, as head of this committee,
he talked to Stimson. In effect he said to Stimson, "What's going on?
Here's all of the stuff that I get, and I don't know what it means. What's
going on?"
Stimson said to him, "Senator, this is one thing that I'm going to have
to call a halt on and not tell you. At the same time, I'm going to have
to ask you to let it lay. Stop any investigation that you're making. Don't
do anything further. I ask you to do this as a matter of complete national
security.
Stimson, as I say, was there in Potsdam at the meeting. When he received
this telegram
[315]
on July 16, he went to the President and told him that we
had an atomic bomb and that it could be used against Japan. As it turned
out after the war, when facts began to come out, we had only had two bombs,
beyond the experimental one that was touched off in the top of that tower
in the New Mexico desert. They were both subsequently used.
HESS: What is your personal opinion, do you think those bombs should
have been dropped?
NIXON: Well, here again, no one is entitled to make snap judgments about
these things, as to should it have or shouldn't it have. The answer has
to come in knowing what the facts were., not in hindsight. We were engaged
in a war against a double foe. We were fighting for our national life.
The President had been told, he told me later, by his advisers (General
George Marshall, the Army Chief of Staff,
[316] and others), that if we had
to invade Japan proper, the Island of Honshu, that we could expect to
lose a million men. Now this was the military estimate.
It had been learned, in the fighting to take over that lower Japanese
island, that the Japanese were fierce, and that they were going to make
a last-ditch stand. As Truman was told, we could expect to lose another
million American boys. Well, that's a pretty big loss isn't it?
Truman had to make the decision. But he asked the opinion of his top
people. He told me coming back on the Augusta after the first bomb
was dropped on Hiroshima, that every person that he had talked with had
said, "Yes, drop the bomb." George Marshall, and every one of Truman's
advisers had said, "Drop the bomb."
HBSS: Did he imply or state that there had been any serious discussion
not to drop the bomb?
[317] NIXON: No.
Truman said he was given this advice in order to end the war. As he said,
"To save the lives of a million American boys" who would be lost if they
had to invade the Island of Honshu. This was to compel the Japanese surrender
before there was an invasion, which, incidentally, had already been wrapped
up. I forget at the moment the date. But we had set the date for the invasion.
I think it was around October 15.
HESS: The name of that proposed invasion was the Olympic Coronet.
NIXON: I never knew the code name.
Truman said the same thing for the reasons that the Russians were brought
into the war against Japan. Afterwards there was a great deal of criticism.
Many people said it wasn't necessary at all. Well, George Marshall thought
it was necessary. Chester Nimitz thought it was necessary.
[318] The military
mind, of course, doesn't take anything for granted. Until the foe surrenders,
if they are still fighting with all of their power, you don't have any
guarantee of victory on your part. They may smash you. So, Truman told
me that Marshall and others had said, "Yes, get the Russians into the
war."
This couldn't be done until after the German surrender. The reason was
very simple--military logistics. The Russian army was fighting in Western
Europe. The Japanese Islands are half way around the world, thousand upon
thousands of miles away. There was a one-track railroad running from Moscow
to Vladivostok.
I never thought the Russians were needed. This gave Russia the right
to increase their possessions in the Pacific area. But, why not? I felt
we wouldn't have to ask the Russians to join us. When things were cleaned
up with Germany, if it was to their national advantage
[319] to join us in a
war against Japan, they would. They didn't have to be asked. If they didn't,
they wouldn't. So, there you are.
Anyway, this particularly came true after the atomic bomb was dropped.
But who knew that that would happen? I understood, initially, that the
agreement was made at Yalta that the Russians would come into the war
against Japan three months after the surrender of Germany.
Well, coming home on the Augusta, Truman told me this same thing:
Stalin had agreed that Russia would come into the war against Japan approximately
three months after the German surrender and this would be August 8. And
the Russians did enter the war.
HESS: Exactly three months after V-E Day.
NIXON: Yes. That's right, May 8th to August 8th. So, they did carry out
one of their agreements.
HESS: When it was to their benefit.
[320]
NIXON: That's the way a nation has to work. Self interest is a powerful thing.
But Truman said, "Bob you can't use it. When we get home, you mustn't
write this until I give the official word on it." So, here I was, nursing
a story in my bosom of tremendous magnitude. Because Russia coming into
the war against Japan was important, but I kept the faith.
On the same day Stimson told Truman about the successful explosion, Truman,
Stalin, and Churchill met around the conference table. (Truman told me
this on the way home on the Augusta.) When the meeting broke up
at the end of the day, Truman said, "I walked over to Stalin and said
to him, 'Generalissimo, we have a new weapon. A very powerful weapon."'
Stalin didn't seem to be surprised at all. As we learned afterwards,
the Russians knew what we were after, and everything about it, down to
the complete blueprints.
[321]
Anyway, Truman said, "Stalin didn't seem surprised at all. He just asked,
'What are you going to do with it."'
Truman said, "I said, 'I'm going to win the war with it."' And that was
it.
I have read other accounts that differ in some degree, but this is what
Truman told me in his own words coming back aboard the Augusta.
HESS: What other events come to mind when thinking about Potsdam, and
events in Germany? Have we pretty well covered the Potsdam Conference?
NIXON: All the problems that were covered, or partially covered, have
all come out and have been discussed one way or another. There's no need
for me to try to go over them because they've all been printed by others
who attended these conferences. Mind you, I didn't attend any of these
conferences. I was there to report what I could of the events around
the conference.
[322]
No one outside of those attending the conference knew
what was going on. My first information about it was from a very carefully
worded joint communiqué put out by the three governments around
midnight after the last session of the conference.
HESS: On the trip back, the President stopped in Plymouth, England. He
visited King George, is that correct?
NIXON: Yes, that is right.
But first, during this conference, Stalin had an attack of diplomatic
illness in the middle of the conference. He was piqued by something, or
he had his own reasons for wanting to slow up the conference. It was on
this occasion that we flew down to Frankfurt and went up into the hills
for this luncheon and meeting with Eisenhower. It was at this luncheon
that Truman, with his then adjulation of Eisenhower, had told Ike, "If
you'd like to be President,
[323] there's an election coming up in 1948, and
I'll help."
HESS: Did Mr. Truman tell you about this?
NIXON: Yes, later.
I remember now what I wanted to say in connection with the way the conference
operated. Truman came away from the Potsdam Conference a very frustrated
man. They had spent days and days trying to get a postwar structure for
peace. Truman said that the non controversial areas were easily covered,
but any time anything came up about the future of Poland, Czechoslovakia,
Austria, or reparations, Stalin would stall and suggest that it be referred
to the Foreign Ministers.
Here were three heads of state sitting around a table, when one objected
to a settlement it could either die or be referred to the Foreign Ministers.
The only way to keep it alive, as
[324] Truman said, was to "refer it to the
Foreign Ministers."
The net result was that Stalin was exercising his right of veto on almost
everything of importance, and they were getting nowhere. So, Truman came
away from Potsdam in complete frustration. Some of the things that he
said about Stalin on the Augusta coming back, were not too polite.
HESS: What did he say?
NIXON: The upshot of it was, that Stalin was a stubborn, obstinate man.
You just could not get anywhere with him. You could tell from what Truman
was saying that he didn't like the way Stalin had acted.
Mind you, Truman was put in an untenable position with all this vetoing
going on. Here were two strong-willed people (Stalin and Churchill) pulling
and tugging at each other for
[325] years of war. They had made Roosevelt the
chairman of these past round table meetings, and at the first meeting
at Potsdam, they agreed that Truman should be the chairman of the conference.
You know what a chairman does. His job was to introduce subjects. So,
apparently, almost every time Truman would try to do something, Stalin
would politely, but firmly, oppose it. They just were getting absolutely
nowhere.
As I've said before, the Potsdam Conference was just more or less a continuation
of the Yalta Conference. So, Truman was a very frustrated man when he
was coming back across the Atlantic. He had had great and high hopes of
something really getting accomplished at Potsdam.
HESS: What did he have to say about his impressions of Mr. Churchill
and Mr. Clement Attlee?
NIXON: Well, frankly, that's just a blank to me.
He was a great admirer of Churchill. There
[326] was a British war leader of
such great stature and strength, and Truman looked up to him.
I don't recall what he said about Clement Attlee, except that in the
middle of the conference Churchill left, and Attlee took over.
HESS: Do you recall anything in particular about the stop in England
and the visit between Mr. Truman and King George?
NIXON: Yes. When the conference broke up, Truman flew directly to Plymouth.
The plane I was on flew to London and stopped there briefly before going
on to Plymouth. We were then taken in RAF jeeps, or sedans, over to Plymouth
where the President was aboard the Augusta. King George VI, a tall
fine looking man in middle life, was aboard the British battleship King
George V. King George came over in a launch to call on the President,
and the President presented him
[327] an autographed photograph of himself.
King George had also brought along an autographed photograph of himself
for Truman.
Truman took King George for a tour of the Augusta. I remember
I was standing along the side and as Truman passed me with the King, he
punched me in the ribs and grinned. You don't get to see kings every day,
especially if you are a farm boy from Missouri.
Then Truman and the King went over for a visit to the King George,
the battleship. This was an exchange of visits. They visited with each
other and talked and chatted. Then Truman came back to the Augusta,
and we started home.
That about wraps up the Potsdam phase of it, but not the troubles that
were to come later.
HESS: That's right. The Augusta got back on August the 7th. What
comes to mind when you look back on V-J Day?
[328]
NIXON: Well, by this time it was becoming increasingly apparent that
the war was over. Truman announced that the first bomb had been dropped
while we were aboard the Augusta. As a matter of fact, he went
into the enlisted men's mess to make this announcement. (I was having
lunch in the officer's ward room.) It was only after he went to the enlisted
men that he came into the officer's ward room and made this same announcement
in a rather prim fashion, it seemed to me.
It was so obvious that he was dealing with something that he didn't know
very much about. Who did? But he was using phraseology that was completely
strange and new to him, as it was to everybody else. They had prepared
ahead of time a lengthy press release from which he read. I remember,
that he said: "We have chained the power of the sun," and "we have made
an atomic bomb, and it has been dropped on the
[329] city of Hiroshima in Japan.
One bomb, with the power of 20,000 tons of TNT has destroyed an entire
city." The phraseology sounded like clichés, which he had no part
in putting together, but from which he was taking his announcement.
With the mention of the atomic bomb having the power of 20,000 tons of
TNT, a number of these young lieutenants and ensigns later jumped from
the table, went to their quarters, and came racing back with slide rules
so they could mathematically figure out what this really was.
HESS: How big of a blast it was.
NIXON: I remember any number of them said, "This means the surrender
of Japan. It just has to be all over." No one, of course, except those
who had built this bomb, knew that there were only two of them. And that,
I might add, included the Japanese. They didn't have any
[330] idea whether
we had one or one thousand.
HESS: That's why the secret was so well-kept.
NIXON: If we could drop two of them, they had to assume that we could
destroy every city they had. It became obvious they had to surrender.
Like Churchill had said a long time earlier: "If Hitler is able to split
the atom, it's all over." That's the only thing that would have made the
British surrender. Hitler would not have hesitated to destroy London,
completely, and everything else in England. Except he would have saved
the industrial centers for his own use. Wherever the civilians were concerned,
he would have had no hesitancy. As a matter of fact, in some of the speeches
that he made during the war, both he and Goering hinted at new, devastating
weapons that were in the making. As it turned out, these were the V-1s
and the V-2s. But they were trying to split the atom
[331] to make atomic warheads
for their rockets.
The following day the Russians came into the war against Japan, dead
on schedule. This to me was the finale. Japan had to surrender. Two of
its cities had been destroyed by atomic bombs, and now the Russian hoards
were turned loose on them.
HESS: Just one on that day, because the second bomb was the following
day on the 9th.
NIXON: Well, yes. Thanks for reminding me.
The accumulation of the two bombs and the Russians in the war all within
three or four days, made it obvious. They did surrender on the 14th.
HESS: What do you recall of Mr. Truman's announcement of the surrender?
NIXON: It seemed to be becoming increasingly obvious that it was all
over. The Japanese would have
[332] to surrender. But they did not have to surrender.
Remember we were planning an invasion of Japan, and this was what Truman
was trying to avoid. The Japanese had proved themselves to be a very obstinate
foe. So, as far as we knew, they could have gone right on down to the
end with our having to invade the main island of Japan. However, the events
seemed to indicate an early end.
On the afternoon of the 14th, I was keeping very close watch on the White
House lobby. (It's been changed since. It's been closed off.) But at that
time I saw Admiral Leahy come in from the downstairs steps and go into
the President's office. Other high brass also showed up. Things were beginning
to stir and bustle. Normally the White House lobby, is a quiet place,
not much coming and going. So, when I saw these characters heading unobtrusively
for the President's office, I went to my telephone in the White House
press room. Since then, they have put in a partition there at the end
of the lobby so you can't see
[333] people go back and forth. It wasn't
Eisenhower, but I would guess it was Kennedy who had the partition put in.
I went to my phone, and asked for Bill Hutchison, our bureau chief. I
said, "Well, Bill, you can expect the surrender of Japan any time now.
You might as well get set for it. I'll be on the phone flashing the story."
About an hour later, I guess it was, a press conference was called. The
small group (and it was a very small group), of newsmen who were there,
went into the President's office and stood before his desk. He was surrounded
on both sides by almost every important top person in the Government.
The President announced that the Japanese had surrendered. It was very
brief. We burst out of the side door of his office, racing for our telephones
to flash the story around the Nation. I suppose there was a communiqué
with it; there always was, but that's a little detail that I
[334] don't even
recall, because it was minor. The important thing to remember was the
President's announcement of the surrender of Japan. That was a stupendous
thing because that was the end of the war. The fighting was over. It had
been going on for three months after the Germans surrendered.
HESS: What seemed to be the atmosphere in Washington when the news reached
the general public?
NIXON: It's hard for me to recall. My recollection is that when the President
announced the surrender of Germany on May 8th, there was this tremendous
gathering of people outside the White House fence on Pennsylvania Avenue
and in Lafayette Park, and everybody went crazy. They were acting almost
like they were drunk. They were so happy and overcome. There was just
tremendous public acclamation. It seems to me Truman even went out on
the White House lawn and waved to
[335] the people, but I just don't recall.
When the Japanese surrendered, I have no recollection of this same thing
going on or not. It may have, but it must be remembered that I was a pretty
busy fellow. I was in a telephone booth in the White House press room
churning out, as fast as I could dictate, literally thousands of words,
which takes time. If there was a celebration, by the time I was able to
leave the White House that evening, it had subsided. Apparently the reason
I don't have any recollection of it, was because I was indoors getting
an important piece of work done which required some time.
I couldn't leave the White House until Charlie Ross put "the lid" on.
That meant the business of the day was done. After the President had gone
to his private quarters in the White House, and the events of the day
ended, I could leave.
[336]
Regardless of the hour of the evening, I never left the White House until
I had the assurance from Charlie Ross that it was safe to do so until
the following morning. If anything untoward happened, and there was any
reason for my being there, I would be telephoned by the White House switchboard
at my residence.
It's a confining way to live. It meant that you spent your evenings in
your own home without daring to go out like normal human beings do. You
spent your days in the White House. But you have to do this. They have
to have access to you.
Actually, the scene in the President's office, was quite similar to the
scene on May 8th when he announced the surrender of Germany.
I remember on that afternoon, I came racing out of the President's office,
and through the lobby, and I slipped and flipped completely over, landing
on my left shoulder,
[337] fortunately with my head under me out of the way.
I tore an enormous rip in my jacket, but I had enough momentum behind
me that I just rolled right over, got up on my feet, and got on into the
press room to my telephone booth.
It's interesting to speculate on this atomic bomb thing. What would have
happened had the initial bomb been exploded in New Mexico, not on July
16th, but several months earlier. Would it have been used against Germany?
HESS: What's your opinion? Many people from Asia do not think so. They
think that we would not have used it on a white European nation,
but we would use it on a yellow Oriental nation.
NIXON: I am confident that they are entirely in error. I'm not just guessing
at this either. You have to base your judgments on your knowledge of what
had been recommended to the President, the way the minds of the
military worked, what
[338]
George Marshall thought and believed was necessary.
Both Roosevelt and Churchill regarded the defeat of Germany as the primary
objective of the war. Had this atomic bomb come into being earlier, I
have complete confidence that the bomb would have been used. Let us remember
that there was no diminution of the German fighting until they were in
effect destroyed. A few months before the May 8th surrender, nobody was
predicting that the war was going to be over that soon.
HESS: As I recall, didn't the Germans have jet aircraft that were almost
ready for flying?
NIXON: They were not just almost ready. They were ready and were
used. Our Air Force bombers in England came back from bombing Hamburg
or someplace one day and said, "My god, airplanes without propellers."
They had only a few of them. They had not entered mass production,
[339] but
these tremendously high speed jet fighters were knocking down our Flying
Fortresses all over the place and not being touched themselves because
of the speed.
HESS: I seem to recall a photograph in Life magazine just showing
the interior of a factory with jets. I believe Life estimated that
they would have been ready to fly in two weeks. There were a number of
jets that would have been in the air in two more weeks.
NIXON: It seems to me that I was told that these were underground factories,
too. The German war machine was not smashed by any means. In December
they had come out with what proved to be their final offensive, the Battle
of the Bulge. They almost made it. They hoped to sweep up to Antwerp and
split the British army on the north., and the American Army on the south.
They almost made it. The weather
[340] contributed and so forth. Very bitter
weather and no air power.
Germany was the primary objective, and the attitude of the military was
to use everything that we had to bring the Hitler forces to their knees.
I have every confidence that we would have used the atomic bomb
had it been available several months earlier. What it would have
been used on, that's another matter. Somebody else would have had to decide
that. We had wrought great destruction on Berlin, but really nothing like
the destruction we saw in the end at Potsdam. A great deal of that was
done by Russians in fighting into the city.
HESS: Their house-to-house fighting.
NIXON: Yes, and heavy artillery is a lot more effective than bombs because
you know what you're going to hit with heavy artillery. Bombs just splatter.
You're going to hit something.
[341] It may not be what you're trying to hit,
but it's going to cause a lot of destruction. So, I think the Asiatics
who take that attitude, probably are very wrong. Mind you, Roosevelt would
have been alive. Roosevelt would have been in command. There again, you
have to guess at what he would do. But I have no doubt in my mind what
the recommendation of the military would have been. Our Air Force and
the British air force had wrought devastation all over Germany. But mind
you there were still industrial cities largely intact. We didn't pick
Tokyo for the two atomic bombs there. Tokyo was their capital. What we
picked were industrial cities. The bomb was supposed to knock out their
war machinery, not to kill civilians, but you can't do one without the other.
Roosevelt, before he died, was fully acquainted with the progress on
the atomic bomb. He was the one who had authorized the expenditure of
over two billion dollars. Churchill had sent all of his
[342] atomic scientists
over to this country to help to put it into being. This was really a British
achievement as much, or maybe more, than an American achievement. We provided
the wherewithal to do it, under conditions of complete safety. The British
were being bombed. Not just London was bombed, but every industrial center.
They had no area in this tiny little island of England where they could
pursue this, nor did they have the wherewithal. Their economy was really
shot. They had to live off of us. Had it not been for us, and for Roosevelt,
they wouldn't have made it. That is why I was trying to point out the
devastating blow that Truman's early ending of lend-lease was to these
people.
[Top of the Page | Notices
and Restrictions | Interview Transcript
| Additional Nixon Oral History Transcripts]
|